Summary of “Obesity Paradox” Debunked in New Research:
New research published in the European Heart Journal has challenged the “obesity paradox,” which suggests that overweight or obese heart failure patients have a lower risk of hospitalization or death than those with a normal weight. The study, which looked at different ways to measure patients, including the waist-to-height ratio instead of body mass index (BMI), found that the paradox disappears when measuring patients with waist-to-height ratio. The study analyzed data from 1832 women and 6567 men with heart failure in 47 countries on six continents. Participants were enrolled in the PARADIGM-HF international randomized controlled trial.
*****
New Study Debunks Obesity Paradox in Heart Failure Patients
A new study has debunked the “obesity paradox” that individuals who have heart failure are believed to have a lower risk of hospitalization or death only if they are overweight or obese compared to those of normal weight. The research, published in the European Heart Journal, has found that using waist-to-height ratio (WHtR) measurements instead of body mass index (BMI) eliminates the supposed survival advantage for patients with a BMI of 25kg/m2 or above.
Body Mass Index as an Indicator of Health
Body Mass Index (BMI) is a popular measurement used by doctors to assess an individual’s weight-to-height ratio to estimate body fat and overall health. It may not provide a comprehensive representation of an individual’s health or risk for certain conditions as it has limitations regarding muscle mass or distribution of fat.
The Research Methodology Used
Natriuretic peptides are hormones secreted in the blood when the heart is under pressure. The study, led by Professor of Medical Cardiology at the University of Glasgow, John McMurray, examined patient size and proportions using different methods to calculate their BMI, including anthropometric measurements like waist-to-height and waist-to-hip ratios and natriuretic peptide levels. The researchers analyzed data from 1832 women and 6567 men from 47 countries worldwide.
Elimination of Obesity-Survival Paradox
The study revealed that the supposed obesity-survival paradox showing lower death rates for people with BMIs of 25 kg/m2 or more was less visible when assessing waist-to-height ratios. The paradox disappeared altogether when the researchers adjusted the results to take into account all significant factors that can impact outcomes.
Observing & Improving Patient Outcomes
Obesity is a risk factor for the onset of heart failure. Therefore, the study’s findings raise the fact that weight loss could be beneficial.
Prof. McMurray believes greater adiposity in heart failure patients is associated with worse outcomes, including high hospitalization rates and poor health-related quality of life, and that weight loss programs should be implemented to improve patient outcomes.
Conclusion
The “obesity paradox” is a phenomenon that obese patients with heart failure tend to survive longer than those who are not obese. However, this study’s new research suggests WHtR instead of BMI clarifies the relationship between body fat and patient outcomes in heart failure patients. Moreover, its findings support the revision of the obesity paradox and raise questions about encouraging patients with heart failure to maintain their weight. Instead, the future should see further research on the effectiveness of weight loss programs in obese heart failure patients with a high WHtR.
Comments are closed